Guest blog from Dr. Kel McDowell (school counsellor)

Dear Premier Clark and Minister Fassbender. I have become increasingly disappointed with your government’s stance with the BCTF. I understand the basis of negotiation as I deal with it everyday in my job. In fact, my entire doctoral thesis was on ethics and relations – how parties must first understand the expressed needs of each other during negotiation and then strive to balance these in an ethical and fair manner. I have not seen this on the part of government during this dispute, in fact I’ve seen mostly unethical behaviour and very disturbing leadership – actually quite scary not just for teachers, but for all citizens in a supposedly democratic system.

I understand that your government is from a different side of the political spectrum than either me or members of the BCTF, but I’m not sure why you feel you have the right to dismiss their (BCTF) right to a different political belief and simply try to engineer society to be the way you want it. Ms. Clark, you have made it your personal agenda since 2002 to try and ‘eliminate’ the 41,000 people who are the BCTF – almost like a sort of political genocide – simply because they have a greater social awareness and conscience than you or your government. Furthermore, you don’t really want the public education system to actually ‘work’ as your mandate is to see more people move their children into the private education (for profit) system. I, as well as many others, would argue that you are trying to keep this strike going as long as possible in hopes that more people will move their children into private schools. Would it not be more effective leadership to try and compromise and sustain a lasting relationship with all of the citizens of BC, rather than create a lasting adversarial and provocative one with those who don’t share your views, such as the BCTF (to mention just a few).

For the record many of us, are quite happy to pay taxes, in fact I’d pay even more, if I can be assured at least two basic human rights – health and education – are secured. I am frightened by your ideas of ripping the social fabric out from under all of us – may the rich survive and the poor die. I think your leadership would be much more respected by all citizens (not just those who voted for you) if you took the high road, rather than reverting to what some in this latest dispute would ironically call your high-school drama antics of bullying your adversaries because you are in power. Why not have Mr. Fassbender work with the BCTF and not against them.

My further questions to you (or Mr. Fassbender, although he has no voice of his own, he just speaks for you like some sort of puppet) are:

  • Why are you so adamantly opposed to fair negotiations with labour unions, particularly the BCTF?
  • Why do you want to (or rather why did you) provoke another teacher’s strike?
  • Why do you have a personal vendetta against teachers and public education?
  • Was your own experience so horrible at school that you are angry with teachers and the system?
  • What is your actual stance on public education – do you see it as a human right for all citizens in a democratic society?
  • Do you not feel it is unethical to take public monies to pay for your son’s private education?

I look forward to hearing from you or one of your representatives. I don’t actually suspect I will, because you probably only respond to ‘the converted’, or those who tell you what a good job you are doing. I sincerely hope those converted people still say that in 10 years when we have become another post-Thatcher, Regan, Harper disaster right here in BC. If however, I can use my skills and education, (a public one which subsequently led to my getting a doctoral degree – in ethics), I would be happy to help your government with some advice on how to treat people in a fair and ethical manner. It may actually help you politically – how’s that – coming from someone on the ‘other’ side.

Sincerely,
Dr. Kelross McDowell

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s